Horizontal integration: acquiring a direct competitor
On this page
Do your entities follow the same pricing rules?
Let's plan an exchangeDiscover our Operational Pricing ConsultingHorizontal integration is a strategy through which a company expands by acquiring or partnering with competitors in the same segment of the value chain: acquisition of a retail chain, joint purchasing group, or commercial alliance. In terms of pricing, it strengthens the company’s bargaining power with suppliers and allows for the sharing of pricing tools and strategies.
The Essentials
- Horizontal integration brings together competitors at the same level of the value chain, while vertical integration extends up or down the value chain.
- Forcibly aligning the prices of the two chains drives away customers who are accustomed to the prices of the acquired chain.
- It determines whether the increased purchasing power leads to a price reduction or remains in the profit margin.
In 6 Questions
Acquire or form an alliance with a direct competitor.
Retail chains expanding through acquisitions, purchasing cooperatives.
In the event of a merger, acquisition, or alliance.
Next in the chain: distribution.
Greater purchasing power, shared fixed costs.
Audit price discrepancies, renegotiate, and gradually standardize tools.
Why Horizontal Integration Is a Pricing Lever
Because a larger player can negotiate better terms, which it can translate into higher margins or lower prices.
- Increase bargaining power with suppliers.
- Pool fixed costs: centralized purchasing, logistics, and pricing tools.
- Harmonize pricing practices to avoid conflicting arbitrage opportunities in common markets.
Real-world example: 75 stores, +2.1% gross margin
Two regional home improvement chains are merging, securing an additional 1.8 percentage points in discounts and reinvesting half of that in their prices.
75 stores, gross margin up 2.1% over 12 months
Merger of two regional home improvement chains (40 + 35 stores)
additional discount secured from the main supplier thanks to the purchasing power of the new headquarters (75 stores, €480 million in revenue).
Gross margin over the 12 months following the merger
Average traffic over the 12 months following the merger
The two chains (40 and 35 stores, in non-competing regions) together generate €480 million in revenue. The discount achieved is split between a 0.9-point increase in margin and a 0.9-point decrease in prices on key sales indicators: a 4.5% increase in foot traffic over 12 months.
How Can You Take Advantage of Horizontal Integration in Pricing?
Three initiatives—and a major effort to drive change.
Audit Price Variances
Among entities, prior to any harmonization.
Renegotiate supplier contracts
Once their weight has stabilized, often as early as the first few months.
Gradually standardize the tools
To avoid maintaining two pricing engines in parallel.
Our Operational Pricing Consulting conducts the audit and harmonization; our Pricing Strategy Consulting defines the common positioning. See alsoprice standardization.
The 3 Common Mistakes Made After a Horizontal Integration
Moving too quickly to standardize, underestimating IT, or neglecting the teams.
- Rushing to harmonize rates before understanding the specific characteristics of each entity.
- Underestimating IT complexity: System integration can take several years.
- Ignoring change management: The departure of key experts undermines pricing performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Short answers to the most frequently asked questions about horizontal integration.
What is horizontal integration?
Horizontal integration is a growth strategy whereby a company expands its business by acquiring or forming partnerships with competitors operating at the same stage of the value chain: acquisition of a retail chain, a joint purchasing group, or a commercial alliance.
How long does it take to integrate two pricing organizations?
It takes several years to complete, at different paces depending on the project. Renegotiations with suppliers can begin after a few months, as soon as the cumulative volumes are known. Harmonizing tools takes longer, as it requires time to align product catalogs and pricing rules. Harmonizing work practices is the slowest process: validation procedures, monitored metrics, and pricing culture do not merge at the same pace as an organizational chart.
Should we merge the pricing teams?
It doesn’t have to happen all at once. A transition period with two teams coordinated by a shared governance structure preserves local expertise: each team knows its stores, its local competitors, and its customers. The shared governance structure establishes from the outset the common rules, decisions regarding areas where the two networks overlap, and the convergence timeline. Merging too quickly often leads to the departure of the people who possessed this knowledge, even though it will be invaluable throughout the harmonization process.
What is the risk to the company's reputation?
This is a real risk, especially if harmonization leads to noticeable price increases in certain areas. Customers of an acquired chain instinctively compare the new prices to the ones they were used to, and a price increase on benchmark products is immediately noticeable. Clear communication about what is changing and a phased approach to price alignment can mitigate this risk. Starting with price cuts or less sensitive items also allows for harmonization without giving the impression that the adjustment is being made at the customer’s expense.
Which prices should be aligned first following a merger?
Those items that are common to both chains and visible to the customer, starting with the areas where the two chains overlap geographically. That’s where the difference is immediately noticeable. Non-common shelf stock can wait, and full harmonization generally takes several cycles.
How do you manage two product catalogs after a merger?
This is the task that determines all the others. Until the two catalogs are reconciled, no price comparison is reliable, because the same product code has two different codes. The matching process must therefore precede price harmonization—not accompany it—or else decisions will be made based on incorrect comparisons.
Should we maintain two separate pricing policies?
Temporarily, yes; in the long run, no. Maintaining two policies helps avoid destabilizing client bases during the transition. But beyond a few quarters, the cost of managing two sets of rules and the risk of inconsistencies in shared areas outweigh the benefits of caution.
Key Takeaways
- Horizontal integration brings competitors in the same link of the supply chain closer together.
- It boosts purchasing power, which can be reflected in profit margins or prices.
- Prices and tools are being standardized gradually.
Are you looking to standardize prices following a store acquisition or merger?
Booper helps you standardize your pricing policies following a horizontal merger.
Let's talk about your pricing alignment →Discover our Operational Pricing ConsultingThese articles can interest you
Strategic pricing defines, for a period of six to twelve months, the role of each category, the target price level, and the parameters within which daily prices may fluctuate. It does not set prices; rather, it defines the range within which each price is allowed to fluctuate.
A pricing strategy rarely falls apart all at once; rather, it erodes under the weight of accumulated tactical decisions and an ever-growing list of image products. Drawing the line between strategic, tactical, and operational considerations is more important than the sophistication of the calculations.
A pricing tool project is based on a pricing decision that takes effect today, not on a list of features. The scope defines this decision—an initial, representative but narrow scope—and determines the price once the tool is in place.
The generalization criterion is defined before the test and is evaluated against a control set. There is no requirement to go through an intermediate step between a spreadsheet and a more advanced tool: this often doubles the scope of the project without reducing the risk.