White Paper

Toner and Supplies: Protecting Margins in the Face of Compatible Products and Online Marketplaces

65% of HP’s printing revenue comes from consumables (Annual Report 10-K, fiscal year 2025): this is the profit margin for the entire industry—and the one that remanufactured and compatible products are targeting. Online, shoppers can see within seconds the origin of a product, along with a remanufactured and a compatible option for the same part number, from about ten sellers. Many retailers then match the lowest price without verifying that it is the same product.

This white paper shows how to position each category of printing supplies: compare based on cost per page rather than the price of the cartridge, establish a pricing scale for original, remanufactured, and compatible products with intentional price differentials, manage margins in euros per account, and analyze marketplace prices before following them. Verified figures from 2024 to 2026 (HP, Xerox, IDC, Fevad, Gartner, Quocirca, Decree No. 2024-134).

When you download it, you'll discover

  • Why is the price of a cartridge compared to the cost per page and measured yield, but never across different categories?
  • How to create a pricing structure for original, remanufactured, and compatible products that retains customers without cannibalizing the most profitable segment
  • Why the margin is managed in euros per account: In our example, aligning the origin with a marketplace costs 38% of the margin
  • How can we promote remanufactured products to public buyers, who are required to purchase 20% of their printing supplies from reused sources, rising to 30% by 2030?
  • Which marketplace listings should you follow, which ones should you ignore, and what is the minimum price to sell on them yourself?
The Essentials

Consumables drive the profit margin for the entire printing industry. When competing with compatible products and online marketplaces, a cartridge should be compared based on cost per page—never across different product categories: it’s better to offer the alternative yourself than to be forced to accept it.

65%of HP’s printing revenue comes from consumables for fiscal year 2025HP Inc., Annual Report on Form 10-K, fiscal year 2025
60%cheaper on average for third-party inks rated highest by Which? than for original inks in the United KingdomWhich?, Third-Party Ink Guide, September 2026
30%of public procurement of printing supplies must come from reused sources by 2030, up from 20% in 2024Decree No. 2024-134, February 2024
What You'll Take Away
"Original," "remanufactured," and "compatible" are three types of products, each with its own customer base. Comparing them to one another means aligning with a product that isn't your own.
Cost per page is the only reliable benchmark. The price per box is misleading whenever the yield varies or isn't measured.
The margin is expressed in euros, per account. A customer who downgrades with you is better than a customer who switches to a competitor.
A marketplace price is information, not a directive: only truly comparable offers deserve a response.
Author: Ludovic Shum, Pricing Consultant, BOOPER · Figures verified at the source on October 26, 2026
For whom: Distributors of business supplies and services · 17-minute read · 3 price tiers · 25 pages
BOOPER White Paper: Toner and Supplies vs. Compatible Products and Marketplaces

Free Download

Get the white paper by email.
Thank you! We'll email you the white paper very soon.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
By downloading, you agree to be contacted by Booper regarding this content. Your data will never be shared with third parties.

Give your pricing
the power of predictive analytics.

Plan ahead. Simulate. Decide. Execute.
Let's plan an exchange