Simulate a promotion: incremental, cannibalization, margin
September 29, 2026
A promotion should not be launched in stores without knowing what impact it will have, how it will shift sales to neighboring products or over time, and what it will cost in terms of profit margin. The sales base determines everything else: if it is undervalued, it makes any promotion profitable.
The best way to choose between two scenarios isn't based on uplift, but on the cost per unit actually earned. Under the Egalim cap, the discount depth becomes a budget to be allocated among operations, and each scenario must be able to be replayed and explained.
Simulating a promotion means calculating, before its launch, what it will generate, shift, and cost—scenario by scenario—in terms of the margin for the entire category.
This article explains how to compare scenarios on a common basis, why the baseline is the deciding factor, and how to determine the discount rate when it is capped, using a numerical example.

When you run a promotion, you're making decisions based on profit margin, not volume
At many retailers, a promotion is still judged based on two metrics: the discount rate and the expected sales volume. The rest becomes clear in the financial statements, when the category hasn't really grown.
We've explained in detail how to measure the incremental impact of a promotion after the fact. Here, we're approaching the problem from the opposite angle: quantifying the impact before making a decision, and comparing several options on a common basis.
What a promotional plan must include
A scenario is not “-25% off the benchmark X in week 42.” It is a mechanism, a time period, a store network, a level of visibility, and a projected income statement.
This calculation starts with base sales, adds the response to the offer, subtracts cannibalization and deferred purchases, and adds the halo effect if it has been quantified. It results in the category’s net margin compared to a normal week.
Without these adjustments, we're comparing volumes. With them, we're comparing decisions.
Plan the foundation first, then how to respond to the offer
It all starts with base sales. An undervalued base makes any promotion look profitable: this is the most common—and the most misleading—mistake.
This database must account for seasonality, trends, the calendar, and weather conditions on game days, and must be purged of past promotions.
Next comes the uplift. Our belief is that visibility (flyers, end-cap displays) often carries as much weight as the discount rate. A model that considers only price overestimates subtle discounts and underestimates highly visible promotions.
This is why it is useful to analyze elasticities estimated by product and by store group, rather than using a national average.
Many French people actively look for sales, with 28% doing so systematically before every purchase or store visit.
(OpinionWay for Bonial, press release dated June 13, 2025, more than 10,000 respondents)
A customer base on the lookout for deals automatically leads to delayed purchases of anything that can be stockpiled. A realistic scenario anticipates this before the launch.
Cannibalization, deferred purchases, and the halo effect: the three adjustments
Cannibalization
When a brand of pasta goes on sale at 25% off, some of its new customers reportedly switch to another brand on the same shelf. These sales shift to a different product line, often to one with a lower profit margin.
Intra-category cannibalization Explained in 1 Minute
Read the video transcript
Your new yogurt is a huge hit: 100 units sold! Should we break out the party supplies?
Not so fast... look at the person next to him.
This is what’s known as intra-category cannibalization: a product that takes sales away from a neighboring product on the shelf, rather than generating new sales.
Let's do the math. The new yogurt sells 100 units.
But the older one loses sixty-five. Net gain: thirty-five units!
What if advertising and promotional activities cost more than the profit margin on those thirty-five units? That's a nice-sounding number...
But the launch destroys value.
Be careful—this may be intentional: replacing a low-profit item with one that has a higher margin. The danger lies in involuntary cannibalization.
The pitfall? Judging a promotion without any witnesses.
If sales on the shelf remain flat while the product is flying off the shelves, it has merely shifted sales. Compare this to stores that don't carry the product!
With Booper, AI measures the impact of a price on comparable products, calculates the actual profit from each promotion, and simulates sales and margins before taking action.
Cannibalization: The only thing that matters is what the department actually gains. Keep this in mind!
They are estimated based on the cross-elasticities between the promoted product and its substitutes. The mechanism is explained in detail in our article on cross-elasticity, cannibalization, and the halo effect.
Deferred Purchase
Whether it's laundry detergent, canned goods, or beverages, the customer stocks up their pantry. Sales during the promotional week rise, while sales in the following weeks fall: the scenario must account for this dip.
The Halo Effect
A promotion can also boost sales of the sauce along with the pasta, or a complete meal kit. This benefit exists, but it is often cited without being quantified.
Our rule: A halo that does not have a value specified in the scenario does not exist in the decision.
A numerical example: two scenarios for the same product code
This is a deliberately simple example with fictitious figures. An item sold for €3.00 yields a profit margin of €0.90 and sells 1,000 units per week. Its substitutes yield €0.80 per unit. We are comparing two one-week immediate discounts.
| Indicator | Scenario A –25% | Scenario B –15% |
|---|---|---|
| Price / Unit Margin | 2.25 € / 0.15 € | 2.55 € / 0.45 € |
| Sales of the Promoted Product | 2,600 | 1,800 |
| Additional volume displayed | +1,600 | +800 |
| of which taken from substitutes | 500 | 250 |
| including advance purchases | 300 | 150 |
| True incremental | 800 | 400 |
| Margin on the Promoted Product (base: €900) | 390 € | €810 |
| Cannibalization + carryover + halo effect | -400 -270 +200 = -470 € | -200 -135 +100 = -235 € |
| Net Margin by Category vs. a Normal Week | -980 € | -325 € |
| Cost per unit actually earned | €1.23 | 0.81 € |
In the standard dashboard, Scenario A “wins”: +160% in sales versus +80%. Once adjusted, only half of that volume is generated, and each additional unit costs €1.23 in margin—more than the product’s normal margin.
Scenario B produces half the volume, at a unit cost that is one-third lower.
Neither option is ideal in and of itself. When recruiting for a strategic position, Option A is a viable choice. To support the department’s profit margin, Option B is more reasonable. The key is to make a choice while being aware of the cost of that choice.
Our position: Under the Egalim cap, the discount rate is a budget item
In the mass-market retail sector, the range of scenarios is not unlimited. The cap on promotions limits both the depth and the share of sales volume sold at promotional prices.
a maximum discount of 25% of the annual volume: the cap on promotions for consumer goods, extended through April 15, 2028, by the law of April 14, 2025.
(DGCCRF, guidelines on the regulation of promotions)
A conclusion that is rarely drawn: two discount points granted here mean two fewer points available elsewhere. Depth becomes a scarce resource, to be allocated among operations like a budget.
The right metric, then, is neither uplift nor revenue, but the cost per unit actually earned.
A simulation that can't be replayed is only useful once
When dealing with a sales manager, a buyer, or a supplier, simply saying, “The model recommends B,” isn’t enough. You need to show where the numbers come from—just as you would for any pricing decision: see how to explain a pricing decision.
In practical terms: a stated objective for the operation, scenarios along the same lines, visible forecasting factors, and a record of the decision.
Counterintuitive: A scenario presented without a range is suspicious. An honest promotional forecast should be presented in conservative, balanced, and ambitious versions—not as a single figure.
After the operation, the manager is confronted with the chosen scenario. It is this back-and-forth process that leads to a shift from reactive pricing to predictive pricing.
In an independent hypermarket, simulation serves primarily as a record: each scenario is saved along with its rationale.
Saved, compared, and replayable price scenarios.
The store's strategy: to be the cheapest in the area. Booper serves as a benchmark for comparing prices with competitors, and each scenario is recorded—what was decided, why, and the ability to replay it.
- Issue
- Hold the cheapest position in the zone without losing sight of the margin.
- What Has Changed
- Comprehensive competitive benchmarking and a complete history of pricing scenarios.
Users are enough to drive the hypermarket's price alignment.
Store Management · Independent Hypermarket. Case study written by Booper based on an actual client project; client identity has been anonymized.
The same logic applies to regular prices—with impact simulations before a pricing decision—and to end-of-season sales, with markdowns and markdown.
With Booper, every promotional scenario is costed out before launch: incremental sales, cannibalization, deferred purchases, category net margin, and impact on inventory. Nothing is implemented without approval from your teams.
What if you calculated the costs of your next project before launching it?
Let's talk about your promotionsFrequently Asked Questions
What is a promotional simulation?
This is the pre-launch calculation of what a promotion is expected to generate: sales of the promoted product, sales taken from competing products, purchases that are simply brought forward, and sales gained from complementary products.
The result is shown as the category's net margin, compared to a week without promotions.
How can you prevent sales cannibalization during a promotional campaign?
By estimating this before selecting the product code and depth: cross-elasticities indicate which substitute products will lose sales, and how much profit margin that represents.
We then avoid promoting a product with a lower margin than its competitors, or two similar substitutes at the same time. Cannibalization affects the entire category, not just the single product being promoted.
What is the difference between promotional volume and incremental volume?
Promotional volume is the total amount sold during the promotion in excess of usual sales. Incremental volume represents only the portion that was actually generated, after accounting for cannibalization and deferred purchases.
Is a promotion that reduces profit margins necessarily a bad promotion?
No. A campaign can focus on traffic, recruitment, or pricing strategy. The important thing is that its cost is known before launch: how much does each unit actually cost to acquire, and is that the right price for the objective?
How do I include the Egalim cap on promotions in a simulation?
By treating the rebate depth and the share of volume promoted as capped limits: 34% by value and 25% of annual volume for consumer goods, through April 2028.
The scenarios are then ranked based on incremental cost per unit, to allocate resources where they yield the greatest return.
Which pricing solution addresses cannibalization and cross-product elasticity?
A solution that estimates not only the elasticity specific to each product but also the cross-elasticities within the category, and quantifies each scenario in terms of net margin prior to launch.
It must also make the factors underlying the forecast transparent so that the decision-making process can be discussed. The criteria are detailed in what a promotional management tool must demonstrate.
How can we make promotional arbitration transparent?
By presenting each scenario in the same format—with its forecasting factors and a range—and then documenting the decision. This allows anyone to retrace the reasoning and compare it with the measured result.
Sources
OpinionWay for Bonial, “The French and Consumer Spending,” press release dated June 13, 2025.
Act of April 14, 2025, extending the regulatory framework for promotions through April 15, 2028 (DGCCRF, guidelines).
Example with figures: An illustrative example created for this article, without customer data. Last updated: October 2026.
Quicklizard is a dynamic pricing platform that originated in e-commerce and has been extended to stores with electronic price tags. At Intersport Germany, it manages e-commerce, not the stores.
For a chain of stores in France, look for a software provider with deep industry expertise and built-in compliance with French regulations, such as BOOPER. For an online-focused retailer, consider Competera or Omnia Retail. For market intelligence, try Minderest. In the B2B sector, consider Pricemoov.
Management doesn't approve a price; it approves a trade-off between margin, volume, and price image. Presenting a single recommendation means asking management to trust you. Presenting the cost of each option gives management the information it needs to make a decision.
A sound projection provides a range rather than a single figure, specifies what is being excluded, and anticipates the gap between the projected increase and the actual increase. When compared with actual results, it establishes the credibility of the next projection.
A franchisor cannot impose a minimum resale price: doing so is punishable by law; the franchisor may only recommend a price or set a maximum. A franchisee’s margin is therefore governed by a documented target, defined by network segment and applied uniformly across each segment.
The best indicator of this governance is not adherence to the suggested retail price, but the rate of compliance with it by segment. A suggested retail price that franchisees in a given area do not follow often signals a poorly set price, not a lack of discipline.
