POC pricing: How can you tell if a solution really creates value?
October 20, 2026
A pricing POC is a limited test, conducted using a retailer’s actual data, that compares a solution’s pricing decisions to a baseline scenario measured in the same way. It proves nothing if the scope, baseline, metrics, duration, and resources are not established beforehand.
Three categories of metrics should not be confused: model performance, economic gains, and team usage. And the gain measured within a selected scope is a ceiling, not an average: it should be extrapolated with caution, based on documented assumptions.
A pricing software demo is always impressive: the data is clean, the recommendations are spot-on, and the interface is responsive.
Three months later, the team that launched the POC still doesn't know whether the solution improved the margin by one point or whether the market was simply favorable. The test produced results, not proof.
This article is intended for pricing, procurement, and finance departments that are preparing to test one or more pricing solutions.
It describes what a POC must include to measure actual value creation, and how to compare multiple vendors without giving an advantage to the one that presents itself best.

Short answer: What a pricing POC must demonstrate
A pricing POC (proof of concept) is a test that is limited in time and scope, conducted using a retailer’s actual data, which compares the pricing decisions generated by a solution to a baseline scenario measured in the same way.
It creates demonstrable value when five elements are established before the first recommendation: the scope of the test, the baseline, the selected metrics, the duration, and the resources committed by both parties.
Anything missing from this list at the outset will cost you in the end. Without a baseline, a margin gain may come from the market or the season. Without standard indicators, a solution may produce good recommendations that no one follows.
If the test period is not long enough, the test ends before the models have seen a peak in sales. The rest of the article goes into detail on each of these points, followed by an explanation of how to compare multiple publishers using the same dataset.
Why So Many POCs Don't Prove Anything
Retailers testing a pricing solution lack neither rigor nor goodwill. They run into three areas of confusion that creep in right from the outset.
A demonstration is not a POC
The demonstration is conducted using the vendor's data or a carefully prepared sample of your own data. It shows what the product is capable of.
The POC is run on your data as-is—with all its gaps and duplicates—and demonstrates what the product will do for your organization.
The first can be evaluated in an hour; the second takes several months. Many “POCs” are actually extended demonstrations: access to the platform, a dataset loaded once, a few workshops, and no metrics.
A model's performance is not a gain
Accurate sales forecasts and reliable product matching are good news, but they are technical results.
They do not say whether the suggested retail prices have increased the margin without damagingthe price image. The classic mistake is to evaluate the POC based on the first set of indicators and draw conclusions based on the second.
A free POC is not a cost-free POC
Many publishers offer trials at no charge. The real cost lies elsewhere: in the time spent by the data, pricing, and management control teams—regardless of whether the publisher charges for the service or not.
It is multiplied by the number of publishers being tested, which makes it impossible to test five of them at the same time.
88% of artificial intelligence proof-of-concepts never reach large-scale deployment: for every 33 POCs launched, 4 go into production.
(IDC for Lenovo, CIO Playbook 2025, global survey of IT and business decision-makers, 2025)
These figures pertain to AI in general, not to pricing. The reasons cited (unproven value, data not yet ready, lack of in-house expertise) are, however, the same ones found in tests of pricing solutions.
Choose a scope that speaks to people
The scope of a POC must meet two criteria: it must be small enough to be prepared and monitored with limited resources, yet large enough that any deviation in results is discernible and not merely a matter of chance.
Categories that sell—and sell consistently
A slow-moving or highly seasonal category yields too few observations over a three-month period to draw any conclusions.
The right product mix includes a few product families with consistent weekly sales, active competition, and real pricing leverage (products where the retailer has room to maneuver, not just items whose prices are dictated by the market).
A few hundred to a few thousand items are sufficient.
Similar stores or channels
If the test focuses on retail locations, it must be possible to find comparable locations: same format, same catchment area, same local competition, and similar sales.
A proof of concept (POC) based on the five best stores in the network proves nothing because there are no other stores to use as a benchmark.
A schedule without any disruptive highlights
A POC that includes Black Friday or sales primarily measures the impact of Black Friday or the sales. It’s better to start with a regular period and a medium-sized promotional event.
Our article on the price testing protocol explains how to choose an observation window that is not distorted by seasonal factors or one-time events.
Establishing the baseline
The baseline is what the POC results will be compared to. Without it, any gain is questionable and any loss is excusable. There are two possible approaches, and the best POCs combine both.
Before and after, within the same area
We measure the indicators in the months leading up to the test and then during the test.
It's simple, but fragile: a change in economic conditions, a supplier rate increase, or the entry of a competitor is enough to throw off the analysis. This measure must therefore be supplemented.
Test and indicator, at the same time
We apply the solution's recommendations to a group of stores or categories, and we let a comparable group continue using its usual pricing during the same period.
The difference between the two groups isolates the effect of the solution from anything that affects both groups at the same time.
This method allows you to measure incremental changes rather than simply changes in volume, and it applies to both regular prices and promotional prices.
A driver-versus-witness case, such as the one we handled for a food distribution company.
Each price change is measured against a control group.
The new prices were first rolled out in a few pilot stores and compared to control stores. The results are reviewed weekly and supplemented by an in-store price perception survey.
- Issue
- Move away from a robust but manual method using Excel across multiple retail chains.
- What Has Changed
- Pilot program with a control group, benchmark indices, and capped price fluctuations.
customers surveyed in-store to gauge their perception of the pilot's price.
Pricing Department · Food Retail Group. Case study written by Booper based on an actual client project; the client has been anonymized.
The control group is not a statistical refinement. It is what allows a committee to reach a decision on the outcome without reopening the debate on the economic situation.
The opening figures approved by management accounting
Before running the test, revenue, volumes, and margins for the scope must be calculated in the system and reconciled with those from management accounting, month by month and category by category.
A discrepancy of a few percent indicates a data issue (incorrectly valued purchase costs, unlinked promotions, unaccounted-for returns) that must be addressed before any measurements can be taken.
At Booper, this reconciliation is part of the data integration process: the test doesn't start until the figures from management accounting and those from the platform tell the same story.
Preparing this dataset follows its own set of rules, which are described in our article on the data required for a pricing proof of concept.
Three categories of indicators that should not be confused
A POC is evaluated on three distinct levels. Mixing them leads to false conclusions in both directions: a technically brilliant but unused solution, or a solution adopted with enthusiasm that yielded no results.
| Family of indicators | What it measures | Examples | What She Doesn't Say |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model Performance | The technical quality of the solution's calculations | Accuracy of forecasts for past weeks, reliability of product matching, plausible elasticities by category | If the store makes money |
| Economic Benefits | The difference between the test scope and the baseline | Markup, revenue, volumes, price index relative to competitors, remaining inventory, promotional incremental sales | Whether the teams will use it after the test |
| Use by Teams | Actual adoption of the tool in everyday life | Percentage of recommendations implemented, time required to prepare a price wave, recommendations understood without the publisher's assistance | Nothing, if the other two families are measured as well |
Model Performance Metrics
They evaluate performance based on past data, even before setting a price. Does the solution accurately forecast sales for the past twelve weeks based on historical data?
Is the product matching between your SKUs and those of your competitors accurate, and for what portion of the product lineup?
Are the calculated elasticities consistent with what the teams know about their categories?
These checks take a few weeks and already eliminate solutions that don't match your data. The accuracy of product matching is evaluated, for example, using a manually verified sample.
Economic Gain Indicators
They are the ones who will make the final decision.
Markup s for the test area compared to the control group, sales revenue and volumes (to verify that the margin was not achieved by selling less),the price index compared to tracked competitors (to verify that it was not achieved by raising prices), and remaining inventory at the end of the period.
Booper reports an increase in profit margin of +0.5 to +3 points over the course of a few months: it is precisely through a proof of concept (POC) of this type that the order of magnitude is verified, and our article on the return on investment of a pricing solution explains why the improvement in decision-making is harder to measure—and more significant—than the time savings.
A POC gain cannot be extrapolated as is
A counterintuitive observation from a practitioner: a well-conducted POC almost always overestimates the benefits that will be achieved across the entire product line. This is intentional.
The scope is selected where the value gap is most likely to occur: categories that sell regularly, with active competition and real pricing levers.
The rest of the product line offers less flexibility. Multiplying the test profit by total revenue therefore yields an upper limit, not a forecast.
Our position: Present the results in two figures—the gain measured within the scope of the analysis and a conservative extrapolation to the rest of the product line, with written assumptions.
A finance department that discovers the discrepancy after the contract has been signed withdraws its support for the entire project.
Usage Metrics
These are the factors that are most often overlooked and yet are the most predictive of what will happen after the POC. What percentage of the recommendations did the teams implement, modify, or reject, and for what reasons?
How long does it take to prepare a price wave using this solution, compared to the old process?
Do category managers understand why a price is recommended without having to call the publisher?
A solution whose recommendations are not understood will not be implemented, regardless of its statistical quality; this is the rationale behind the requirements for explainability and auditability of pricing recommendations that major retailers now include in their requests for proposals.
The recommendation adoption rate is a metric that Booper displays on its dashboard, alongside the estimated margin impact.
A high adoption rate for a POC indicates that teams have found the recommendations to be logical and relatable; a low adoption rate, even with strong financial results, suggests that deployment will be difficult.
Duration and resources: three to six months, no less
The duration of a POC is determined by the time required for the economic benefits to become apparent. This involves loading and reconciling data, validating the models using historical data, and then applying and measuring the results over at least two pricing decision cycles.
Three months is the minimum for high-turnover categories; six months is more realistic whenever the test involves a sales campaign or the data requires cleaning.
Illustrative example, fictional figures: In a market where the " Markup " naturally fluctuates by half a point from one week to the next, a real gain of half a point is not noticeable over a four-week period.
It becomes clear when the control group absorbs these fluctuations and several price cycles accumulate. A shorter test measures the speed of implementation, not value creation.
On average, it takes eight months to move from an AI prototype to production, and only 48% of projects succeed in doing so. The primary obstacle cited by 49% of respondents is the difficulty in estimating and demonstrating the project’s value.
(Gartner, survey of 644 organizations in the United States, Germany, and the United Kingdom, May 2024)
On the company side, three people make the difference between a POC that succeeds and one that gets bogged down: a data specialist, a business specialist who implements and comments on the recommendations, and a contact in management control who validates the figures.
Compare Several Publishers on an Equal Footing
When a retailer considers replacing its current solution, it rarely evaluates just one candidate. A comparison is only meaningful if the conditions are the same for everyone.
The same dataset, prepared once
Each publisher receives exactly the same data extracts, documented in the same way, with the same reference figures validated by management control.
Preparing a common data set before selecting candidates prevents the need to redo the work for each one, and—most importantly—ensures that no single publisher has access to a “cleaner” dataset than another. Any discrepancies observed afterward stem from the solutions, not the data.
The same criteria, the same questions
The three categories of indicators listed above serve as a common foundation, supplemented by criteria that cannot be measured using POC: the ability to integrate with the information system, compliance with French pricing regulations, reversibility conditions, and the business model.
Our comparison guide to pricing software ranks the leading providers.
Evaluating Artificial Intelligence Beyond the Demonstration
This is the point where comparisons most often come down to a gut feeling. An AI feature that looks impressive in a demo is evaluated in a proof of concept based on three simple questions.
Is it used on a daily basis—that is, have the teams been using it every week without being prompted by the publisher?
Does it generate analyses that the teams would not have conducted on their own (such as detecting an anomaly, explaining a decline in margins, or weighing two scenarios against each other)?
Do his recommendations include an explanation of the factors behind them, the constraints involved, and the expected impact?
At Booper, every forecast and recommendation comes with an explanation of the factors that influenced it, precisely so that this third point can be verified by the teams rather than simply asserted by the publisher.
Free POC or Paid POC
Both practices exist.
A free POC lowers the barrier to entry but places less of a commitment on the publisher, which can allocate limited resources to it; a paid POC—which is often deductible from the contract if the retailer signs—commits both parties to a timeline and deliverables.
The key criteria are as follows: scope, data provided, metrics, duration, resources on both sides, and decision criteria at the end. A free POC without this framework costs more than a well-defined, paid POC.
A proof of concept without altering the existing tool
Many retailers considering a change in their software solution are still tied to their current vendor by contracts, integrations, and established practices.
This is not an obstacle to the POC, provided that we distinguish between two things: the development of recommendations and the dissemination of prices.
During the test, the candidate solution receives the data, performs calculations, and makes recommendations. The selected prices continue to be processed through the existing system, which remains the infrastructure for distributing them to the cash registers, the website, and the stores.
Nothing changes for downstream systems. This coexistence also makes it possible to compare the recommendations from both tools for the same products and the same weeks—a very telling benchmark for senior management.
It also makes it possible to prepare for a potential transition without rushing it.
Issues related to rule migration, history migration, and contract termination are addressed in our articles on switching pricing tools and on the reversibility of a pricing solution; the POC, however, is not intended to resolve these issues.
The key question is whether the proposed solution adds value to your data.
A written plan before getting started
Objective, scope, data, baseline, indicators, duration, resources, and decision criteria: all of these are documented before the first data upload and signed by the brand and the publisher. This is what turns a POC into proof.
Booper provides this framework to its prospects. It is solution-agnostic and applies to all publishers consulted.
The price diagnostic This step, which often precedes a POC, is used to identify the scope where the value gap is most likely to occur.
Following a successful POC: our guide to implementing a pricing tool and our article on change management.
See also in this feature
- The Booper Solution: Booper Pricing Software
- Selecting and Implementing a Pricing Tool: From Identifying the Need to Going Live
- Pricing tools: comparison of the best pricing software 2026
- Pricing Tool: Definition, How It Works, and Everyday Uses
- Switching from Excel to a Dedicated Pricing Solution: The Complete Guide
FAQ: Defining and Evaluating a Pricing Proof of Concept (POC)
A pricing POC (proof of concept) is a test that is limited in time and scope, conducted using a retailer’s actual data, during which a pricing solution calculates price recommendations that are applied and evaluated against a baseline scenario.
It differs from a demonstration—which is conducted using prepared data and does not measure anything—and from a deployment pilot, which takes place after the purchase decision has been made.
A POC typically lasts three to six months and covers a few product families and a few comparable stores or channels.
By applying the new prices to a group of stores or test categories, while comparable groups maintain their usual pricing during the same period.
The difference between the two groups isolates the effect of seasonal changes, economic conditions, and supplier price increases.
It takes at least two full decision cycles to reach a conclusion. A pricing solution allows you to simulate the expected effect before testing, and then compare it to the observed result.
A pricing platform that combines pre-decision simulation (the impact of a price or promotion on sales, margin, and inventory), the application of prices to a selected scope, and the measurement of results compared to a control group.
Price monitoring tools alone provide competitors' prices but do not simulate or measure them.
Booper offers these three features on a single platform, with a dashboard that tracks the estimated margin impact and the rate at which teams adopt recommendations—two metrics that are directly useful for evaluating a POC.
Between three and six months. It takes time to reconcile the management control data, validate the models using historical data, and then measure at least two pricing decision cycles.
Three months are sufficient for fast-moving categories with data that is already clean; six months are required if the test involves a commercial operation or if the data needs to be cleaned.
For projects lasting less than three months, we measure the speed of implementation, not the value.
BOOPER generally sees a margin increase of +0.5 to +3 points within a few months, depending on the starting point and scope, and a 70 to 90 percent reduction in pricing preparation time.
During the POC, this gain is measured based on your data: the categories or stores being tested are compared to a control group over the same period, in terms of both Markup , and volume, using reliable purchase costs.
Two or three at most, rarely more. Each POC requires time on the retailer's end (data, business operations, management control), and that time is multiplied by the number of candidates.
The comparison is valid only if all participants receive the same dataset—prepared and validated only once—and are evaluated based on the same criteria: model performance, economic gains compared to a baseline scenario, and actual use by the teams.
An initial screening of proposals (based on compliance with French regulations, integration, scalability, and references in your industry) helps narrow down the POCs to those solutions that meet these criteria.
Yes, and that's actually the most common arrangement when a store is still under contract.
The tested solution receives the data, performs calculations, and makes recommendations; the selected prices continue to be processed through the existing system, which remains the infrastructure for distributing them to the cash registers, the website, and the stores.
Nothing changes for downstream systems. This coexistence also makes it possible to compare the recommendations from both tools for the same products and the same weeks.
Issues related to the resumption of regular operations and contract termination are then addressed, if the POC concludes that value has been created.
On three questions, which were assessed rather than stated as facts. Did the AI operate every week without being prompted by the publisher?
Did she produce analyses that the teams would not have done on their own? Does each recommendation include its underlying factors, constraints, and expected impact?
A feature that looks great in a demo but is missing from these three responses should not be a factor in the decision.
The floor price is the price below which a sale cannot be finalized without approval. Together with a target price and a ceiling price, it forms a range that guides the negotiation without locking it in.
The sales rep retains their autonomy, the company maintains its margin, and sales that fall below the threshold become transparent. AI helps set these thresholds by customer segment, provided that the sales rep understands where they come from.
The history shows what price was listed. Traceability shows who decided it, when, on what basis, and with what approval.
It is used to provide evidence during an audit, to justify a price to a supplier, a franchisee, or management, and, above all, to link each decision to its outcome. With AI, it distinguishes between what the machine suggests and what a human decides.
A vague pricing policy works as long as a human makes decisions on a case-by-case basis. When automated, it applies a set of priorities that no one has chosen, across the entire catalog and with every recalculation.
Conflicting objectives, implicit rules, and exceptions that have become the norm must be resolved beforehand. With AI, the stakes are even higher: a poorly defined objective is optimized with formidable precision.
