Horizontal price fixing: aligning prices among similar products
On this page
Is the gap between your private-label brands and the leading brands remaining stable?
Let's plan an exchangeDiscover our product matching solutionHorizontal price linking ties the price of a product to thatof other equivalent products in the same category: two brands of plain yogurt, two power drills with similar features, a national brand and its private label. It maintains consistent price differentials between substitutable products.
The Essentials
- Horizontal linking connects substitutable products to one another, while vertical linking connects the product lines within a product family.
- Setting the gaps in euros rather than as a ratio makes the private-label brand too expensive or too close as soon as the market leader changes its strategy.
- It sets the desired price gap between a national brand and its private label, and maintains it when either one changes its price.
In 6 Questions
A price relationship between substitutable products within the same category.
Pricing teams and category managers.
With every price change in the leading benchmark.
Between a national brand and a store brand, or between competing brands on the shelf.
Keep the product lineup clear and avoid cannibalization.
Ratios (rather than fixed margins) applied automatically.
Why Set Prices in a Horizontal Chain?
Because a stable price difference between substitutable products shapes the customer's purchasing decision.
- Maintaining clarity in the product lineup: a consistent price difference between private-label and national-brand products guides consumer choice.
- Avoid unintended cannibalization: if the gap narrows, one product takes sales away from the other without any benefit to the retailer.
- To make the category manager's job easier, as they focus on managing cohesive product families rather than individual prices.
A concrete example: the pasta aisle
When the leading brand's price increases from €1.89 to €1.99, the prices of its two private-label brands are adjusted by the same percentage.
One move by the leader, two MDDs adjusted proportionally
Pasta aisle · leading brand, national private label, entry-level private label
Price increase for the leading brand (€1.89 → €1.99), due to higher material costs.
National private label, ratio maintained (€1.29 → €1.35)
Entry-level private label, price ratio maintained (€0.89 → €0.94)
The rule: National private label = market leader × 0.68 and entry-level private label = market leader × 0.47. The national private label automatically increases from €1.29 to €1.35, and the entry-level private label from €0.89 to €0.94: the perceived price gaps remain stable.
How do you set up horizontal reinforcement?
By identifying the true substitutes and then setting the ratios applied by the pricing engine.
Substitutable SKUs are identified by their attributes (use, format, value proposition), which requires reliable product matching (see competitive monitoring and product matching). Our solution for product matching, cloning, and chaining then applies the rules automatically. The choice of target price differentials between brands is determined by your pricing strategy. To link product lines together, see vertical chaining.
3 Mistakes to Avoid in Horizontal Chaining
Fake substitutes, discrepancies in euro amounts, or too many rules piled on top of each other.
- Defining imperfect substitutes: Two yogurts with different health claims are not equivalent in the eyes of the customer.
- Maintaining a fixed margin in euros: €0.40 makes sense at €1.89, but much less so at €0.99.
- If you have too many rules for a single item, the engine becomes unpredictable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Short answers to the most frequently asked questions about horizontal chaining.
What is horizontal chaining?
Horizontal price linking ties the price of one item to that of other equivalent items within the same category, typically among substitutable products: two brands of plain yogurt, two similar hole punches, two colors of the same textile item.
What is the difference between horizontal and vertical tie bars?
Horizontal linking connects substitutable products at the same level, such as two competing brands or a private label and its equivalent national brand. Vertical pricing links the different tiers within the same product family: entry-level, mid-range, and premium. The former prevents customers from finding two interchangeable products at inconsistent prices, while the latter ensures that each move up the product line results in a clear price difference. A well-managed product category often combines both approaches, for example, in the plain yogurt aisle.
Should we use a ratio or a fixed margin?
It’s more of a ratio. A fixed markup in euros loses its meaning when prices change: the same markup carries significant weight on an entry-level product but becomes negligible on a much more expensive one. A ratio—for example, a private label price set at a certain percentage of the national brand’s price—maintains the margin as perceived by the customer even when inflation or a renegotiation causes the price of the benchmark product to change. It also eliminates the need to manually recalculate each margin after every price increase.
What are the benefits for retailers?
A clearer pricing structure for the customer, who sees consistent price differentials between comparable products instead of prices set on a case-by-case basis. There’s also less unintended cannibalization: when two interchangeable products are too close in price, the less profitable one can capture sales from the other without anyone intending it. Finally, pricing is managed by coherent product families rather than on a product-by-product basis, which reduces the number of decisions that need to be made and limits inconsistencies when the benchmark product’s price changes.
How do you choose the reference point for a horizontal chain line?
We choose the best-selling and most consistent model over time—not the most expensive or the most iconic one. A model with low turnover or that is frequently out of stock creates instability across the entire line. The model should also be the one whose price customers pay the most attention to, so that consistency is evident where it matters most.
Does horizontal linking work between national brands and private labels?
Yes, and that is one of its most useful applications: maintaining a clear distinction between the private label and the equivalent national brand. The distinction must remain broad enough to justify the private label’s positioning, without becoming so wide that it undermines the product’s perceived quality.
Should we chain together different formats of the same product?
Almost always, because the inconsistency is immediately apparent. A large size that costs more per liter than the small size stands out on the shelf and undermines consumer confidence. Horizontal pricing across sizes is therefore one of the few cases where the rule protects both the price image and the margin.
Key Takeaways
- Horizontal linking relates the prices of substitutable products.
- It relies on ratios to keep perceived discrepancies stable.
- It limits cannibalization and makes the product lineup easier to understand.
Do you want to maintain a consistent product lineup within each category?
Booper applies horizontal chaining automatically, without manual intervention product by product.
Let's talk about the differences between brands →Discover our product matching solutionThese articles can interest you
Product matching is the foundation of competitive monitoring: it prevents companies from lowering prices based on a false price difference between two non-equivalent products. Cases of doubt are referred to business-unit review.
According to Diamart Group (2026), about 50% of French retailers still perform their price matching manually, while 94% collect competitive data.
We structure decisions, not an organizational chart. The hybrid model—the most common one—is defined by what headquarters prohibits, and the role that is most lacking is not that of the analyst but that of the executor, who ensures that the price decided upon is indeed the price displayed.
A single approver per type of decision and a delegation threshold known to everyone are better than an exhaustive matrix. In B2B sales, the key issue is discounts granted beyond the standard pricing schedule.
Most pricing dashboards measure what is easy to collect—Price Index —rather than what indicates whether the strategy is working. An index measures a position, not a result.
Three metrics are more important: the margin by product category, the difference between the set price and the actual price charged, and the rate of deviations from the rules. Price perception, on the other hand, is measured among customers, not in a spreadsheet.